Scarmaouche shouldnt be a catalyst, he should have a sword or a bow. Lisa is an electrical catalyst so Scarmaouche would be just like her. No one has an electrical sword so I think that he should have that. I'm disappointed to see otherwise.
bro we have keqing as a sword and fischl as bow. If he was the first male catalyst that would be cool. And if he is 5 star which he obviously would be. His animations would for that would 100% be sexy I swear. It's Scaramouche we talking about here.
keqing is electro sword, and there are already several examples of characters with the same vision & weapon type: diona & ganyu, hutao & xiangling, qiqi & kaeya & ayaka. if mihoyo were to go by your expectations, we'd only have a total of 7 characters. what's important is not whether they have the same weapon & vision, but their abilities & potential.